Peaker Plant Gas Line Debacle

Peaker Plant Gas Line Debacle

Enbridge Gas has formally commenced construction in Pottageville and Kettleby on a 17 km gas pipeline, beginning at the York Energy Centre at 18731 Dufferin Street in the Holland Marsh. Construction will end at the westerly end of Pottageville near the 8th Concession.

Passing in front of homes and the Kettleby Public School, it will follow the Lloydtown Aurora Rd. through Pottageville, passing in front of the Kettleby School and under Hwy. 400 before it turns north at Jane.

The pipeline is 16 inches wide; the pressure is 650 psi (pounds per square inch.) In contrast, a pipeline taking gas to your house for heating & cooking is less than 5 psi.

The pipeline will be constructed within existing road allowances.  However, the OEB recognizes that temporary easements over some properties along the route will be necessary due to the intrusive nature of the construction.  Over and above undetermined risks of such a facility,  Lloydtown Road will be a mess during this construction period.

Do you know why?

This gas line is to fuel Pristine Power’s “Peaker” gas-fired electric generating station in the Holland Marsh, and the closest connection point to Enbridge’s gas distribution system is in Pottageville.

WHAT ARE THE SAFETY RISKS?

They are concerning.  Please read the following report prepared for and submitted to King Council in January 2010.  It was prepared by East Gwillimbury Councillor Candidate Katharine Parsons, B.A. (Chem.), Executive Director, Global Environmental Action Group and Charles Rhodes, P. Eng., Ph.D. You will find it compelling reading.

Natural Gas Pipeline Setbacks and Risks paper


How did this happen?

Without King Township intervening, The Ontario Energy Board approved construction of this project in April 2010, on the express condition that work commence before year-end. The OEB denied a request by participants to included the pipeline in the environmental assessment of the plant itself.

You can see the full copy of the OEB Decision EB-2009-0187 here, including its graphic in Appendix B of the pipeline’s planned route I have reproduced in this article.

WHAT SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED


Unlike Bill, I would have voted on April 28, 2008 to declare King Township an unwilling host to the generator.

At this Council meeting Councillor Cober, Mayor Black, and 2 others voted against making this declaration: Read the Council discussion and witness the recorded vote here (starting bottom Page 7 with the recorded vote on Page 14).  In May and June all other municipalities passed resolutions denying being willing hosts. At an emergency meeting on July 2, 2008 King Council finally declared itself an unwilling host. Too little – too late.

I would have voted in September 2008 to pass an interim control bylaw in King Township which would have prohibited construction of the generator starting for two years as zoning was reassessed in the Township.  This in turn would have likely delayed the gas pipeline. At this Council meeting Mayor Black and Councillor Cober and two others voted against this bylaw. Council finally passed this bylaw in January 2010. Too little – too late.

King Township didn’t participate in the Ontario Energy Board hearings for Enbridge’s application for approval to build the pipeline. Nothing on the public record suggests Bill Cober asked the Township to participate.

In stark contrast, several groups registered as participants and challenged the OEB as to the safety of the proposed route.

I would have asked for the support of the Mayor and other Councillors for the Township to participate in the hearing and to challenge the risk of a high pressure gas pipeline 34 meters in front of the Kettleby Public School bus loading area and even closer to homes in Pottageville.

Please comment below. After all – it’s YOUR community.

Pristine Power Peaker Plant Gas Pipeline Route

Planned pipeline route through Pottageville and Kettleby. From Ontario Energy Board Decision EB-2009-0187 Appendix B.

3 Comments

  1. After bringing this question up at an all candidates meeting recently, Cober and Black’s true colours came out. When asked why a safer less populated route was not chosen,Cober stated that this a on a regional road and that King’s hands were tied. He was elected to council to fight on our behalf. I will be voting for Greg because I want my councilor to have a backbone when issues come to the table. A friendly smiley face will not stop a pipeline.

  2. Vicki Venchiarutti

    I am completely flabergasted that this was not stopped by Bill Cober and Margaret Black. I was never given the right to vote against this and that is wrong! This is subjecting my home and street in Pottageville to potential extreme danger in the event there is a leak of gas/ explosion. I quite frankly am disgusted by this . Greg Locke will get my vote.

  3. This is one more reason that our existing King Township government needs a complete overhaul. Bill Cober does not deserve another term. We need change and accountability!!!!

Leave a Reply